OPINION SURVEY ON THE NEED TO RESTORE THE SG PINANG AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF A RIVER EDUCATION CENTRE

1.Where are you from?

Malaysia

Southeast Asia

Other Asia

Oceania

Europe

North America

South America

Africa

Others

2.If Malaysian, which state are you from?

Perlis

Kedah

Penang

Perak

Selangor

Negri Sembilan

Melaka

Johor

Kelantan

Terengganu

Pahang

Sabah

Sarawak

Kuala Lumpur

Labuan

Not Malaysian

3.What is your gender?

Male

Female

4.What is your age group?

< 21

21-30

31-40

41-50

51-60

61-70

71+

5.What is your level of education?

Post graduate (Masters & PhD)

University (Bachelor)

Diploma

High school/Upper Secondary (Form 4-Form 6)

Middle school/Lower Secondary

Primary school

< Primary school

6.What is your income level?

< RM500 per month (<US$143)

RM501-RM1000 per month (US$143-US$285)

RM1001-RM2000 per month (US$286-US$570)

RM2001-RM3000 per month (US$571-US$856)

RM3001-RM4000 per month (US$857-US$1142)

RM4001-RM5000 per month (US$1143-US$1428)

RM5001-RM7500 per month (US$1429-US$2143)

RM7501-RM10,000 per month (US$2144-US$2857)

> RM10,000 per month (> US$2857.00)

7.How do you rate the overall cleanliness of the Sg Pinang?

Very clean

Clean

Average

Dirty

Very dirty

Don't know/No Idea

8.How do you rate the overall scenic quality of the Sg Pinang?

Very beautiful and scenic

Quite scenic and pleasing

Average

Dirty and ugly

Very dirty, ugly & disgusting

Don't know/No Idea

9.How do you rate the water quality of the Sg Pinang?

Very pure, fresh & pristine

Quite pure & fresh

Average

Quite polluted

Very polluted

Don't know/No Idea

10.How often do you visit/walk/go pass the Sg Pinang?

Very often (e.g. almost everyday)

Quite often (e.g. once a few days)

Average (e.g. once a week)

Seldom (e.g. less than once a month)

Very seldom (e.g. once in a few months or less)

Never

Don't know/No Idea

11.Do you think it is necessary to clean up & restore the Sg Pinang?

Absolutely necessary

Necessary

Maybe

Unnecessary, it is a waste of time and money

Totally unnecessary, as the river is beyond restoration (it is so dirty that no amount of cleaning can restore it)

Don't know/No Idea

12.Whose responsibility is it to restore & clean up the Sg Pinang?

Government

Private sector (businesses/industries)

Non-Governmental Organisations (NGO)

Government & Private sector

Government & NGO

Private sector & NGO

Government, Private sector & NGO

People who live along the river

All stakeholders

It is Everybody's responsibility

Don't know/No Idea

13.Who should pay for restoring & cleaning up the Sg Pinang?

Government

Private sector (businesses/industries)

Non-Governmental Organisations (NGO)

Government & Private sector

Government & NGO

Private sector & NGO

Government, Private sector & NGO

People who live along the river

People/businesses who pollute the river

All stakeholders

Tax citizen in the country

Don't know/No Idea

14.Are you willing to contribute towards the restoration & clean-up of the Sg Pinang?

Yes, I am willing to contribute cash

Yes, I am willing to give my time as a volunteer

Yes, I am willing to do both the above 1 & 2

Maybe

No, I am not willing to contribute anything

Don't know/No idea

15.If you are willing to contribute cash to the Sg Pinang restoration & clean-up, how much would you contribute?

< RM10

RM11-RM50

RM51-RM100

RM101-RM200

RM201-RM500

RM501-RM1000

RM1001-RM5000

RM5001-RM10,000

> RM10,000

Not sure

Not applicable (for those not willing to contribute cash)

16.If you are willing to contribute your time to the Sg Pinang restoration & clean-up as a volunteer, how much of your time would you contribute?

1 hour a week

2 - 3 hours a week

4 - 5 hours a week

6 - 10 hours a week

11 - 20 hours a week

21 - 30 hours a week

> 30 hours a week

Not sure

Not applicable (for those not willing to contribute time)

17.Sg Pinang is one of the rivers targeted & given funds by the Malaysian Government for restoration in the 9th Malaysia Plan. Water Watch Penang is proposing that the government should build a "River Education Centre (REC)" on the banks of the river. This REC will consist of a river museum where the public and school children can learn about the river's hydrology, flora and fauna, water quality etc. It also has a mini theatre for nature films and talks, science laboratory for research, a canteen, toilets for joggers and walkers, and other facilities for the public to use. Do you think this is a good idea that the REC should be built?

Absolutely yes, this is a fantastic idea. Good for public awareness & education

Yes, I support this innovative idea.

Not sure, I am not convinced whether this idea will work or not

No, I am against this idea

Absolutely no, this is a foolish idea. It is a waste of public funds

No comments

Don't know/No Idea

18.If this River Education Centre is built, will you and your family use its facilities?

Yes, definitely

Yes, most likely

Maybe

No, not likely

No, definitely not

No comments

Don't know/No Idea

19.If this River Education Centre is approved, how much money do you think the government should spend building it and all its facilities?

< RM500,000

RM500,001-RM1 million

RM1 million-RM2 million

RM2 million-RM3 million

RM3 million-RM4 million

RM4 million-RM5 million

RM5 million-RM10 million

> RM10 million

No comments

Don't know/No Idea/Not sure

20.Once the River Education Centre is built, funds are needed to run it, considering we will need staff, utility costs, research materials, stationery, etc. How much money do you think the government should spend running the REC?

< RM5000 per month

RM5001-RM10,000 per month

RM10,001-RM20,000 per month

>RM20,000 per month

The REC should be self-sustaining by charging entrance fee, donations, sponsorship from companies/factories, use of unpaid volunteer staff, etc

Initially, the government should fund the REC operational costs for a year. Then the REC should look for its own finances and be self-sustaining from the 2nd year onwards

Privatise the NEC and let a professional business run it. Then the government will not have to pay the operational costs. But the NEC's ownership must remain with the government

No comments

Don't know/No Idea/Not sure

21.Do you think it is now possible to clean up & restore the Sg Pinang to its original, natural pristine condition in the 1900s where the waters are crystal clear and unpolluted, and udang galah, haruan, grass carp, jelawat, belut, etc were found in abundance?

Absolutely possible if everyone - government, business & public - puts their hearts & minds to it - "Malaysia Boleh"

It is possible if everyone is committed and works very hard

Maybe possible

Not possible, I have serious doubts that we can do this given the public' pathetic behaviour towards rivers

Absolutely not possible, if possible it would have been done a long time ago. I think nobody cares about rivers. Rivers are only good as open sewers and garbage dumps!

No comments

Don't know/No Idea